QPR v Swansea

It will be a brave choice by Warburton because he will be in the firing line if he does choose Kelly and Kelly then makes a mistake himself!

It should be a good footballing game but that could also make it quite tight and tactical with both clubs trying to do the same thing.

I personally think he will stick with Lumley but expect Kane to start over Rangel. I also fancy he may bring in Pugh. I expect Smith will definitely drop out, but whether that is for Scowen, Chair or Pugh is up for debate!

I also wonder if Ball will replace Cameron who usually struggles with 3 games in a week?

I'd go:

Kelly
Kane Hall Barbet Manning
Amos Cameron
BOS Eze Pugh
Hugill

Lumley is a good shot stopper
But he tends to struggle playing it out from the back
Kelly is good at playing the ball out with his feet to others
It’s a tough call as Kelly is a smaller keeper and is a bit unpredictable
I think what northwest has said,warburton will stick with Lumley
Swansea will press and the ball will need to be played out quickly and accurately to other players

Lots of valid points about both Lumley and Kelly but for my money Lumley is the better goalkeeper. If I was Warburton I'd stick with Lumley.I know we have only seen Kelly play a couple of times in pre season and a cup game but my initial impression is that his positioning isn't as good as Lumley. Neither goalie is heavy set and both are on the slight side but whilst Kelly is 6ft 2in when you see him up against 6ft 5in Lumley he does look a lot smaller.

Rangel will definitely be rested tonight and whilst I prefer Cameron to Ball or Scowen I can also see Warburton thinking of playing Amos alongside Smith. BOS was our best player against Bristol but Chair certainly did well when he came on and deserves a starting place. I also prefer Wells to Hugill but Warburton only currently has eyes for the West Ham loanee.

I think Warburton will go with the folowing;

Lumley
Kane, Hall, Barbet,Manning
Amos, Smith
BOS,Chair,Eze
Hugill

Swansea look silky smooth on the ball attacking
But their defence is a bit open at times
I think we got to try to not think we can play exactly the same as them
Swansea have played the same for many seasons and we haven’t
I can’t see anything other a narrow defeat im afraid

Anyone got a link to the game? I ask because I do not have a 'Sky Red Button'!

Ball not even on the bench with Scowen returning to take his place amongst the subs. Rangel not in the squad altogether either.

A few players like Smith, Amos and Hugill need to up their games tonight to warrant further play.

0 -1 Swansea and it all came from a QPR corner.

Have to give Swansea credit, they do look composed and look a very decent team.